top of page

Quotes

Many authors have discussed coherence in science education and in related domains. Below are quotes which best reflect a notion of coherence which is context-dependent, subjective, and dynamically constructed. 

Lakoff and Johnson, Metaphors We Live By

"Meaning is not cut and dried; it is a matter of imagination and a matter of constructing coherence. The objectivist emphasis on achieving a universally valid point of view misses what is important, insightful, and coherent for the individual."

David Hume, A Treatise of Human Nature

"...there is a secret tie or union among particular ideas, which causes the mind to conjoin them more frequently together, and makes the one, upon its appearance, introduce the other..."

Kelly & Crawford (1997)

"​For example, the epistemological commitment of a discipline to internal consistency, may serve as a heuristic for students attempting to learn the requisite knowledge of the field (Hewson, 1985). Nevertheless, the recreation of “internal consistency,” or what counts as internal consistency, may be differentially acknowledged and understood by students in various contexts...Rather than assuming that internal consistency serves as a heuristic (which it might very well do) we draw on cognitive anthropology (Spradley, 1980; Zaharlick & Green, 1991) and ask: Internal consistency to whom, for what purpose, for what reason, for what intended outcomes?"

Girod & Wong (2002)

"U]nderstanding is not most often driven by practical or instrumental purposes. The desire for understanding is driven by something more human. It is people's nature to seek connections-connections to others, to the earth, and to ideas. This sense of connectedness is not only at the level of individual cognition; it comes from a desire to know with one's heart and mind, emotions and cognitions, imagination and reason."

bottom of page